Central Europe Review find out about advertising in CER
Vol 2, No 18
9 May 2000
 CER INFO 
front page 
overview 
sponsor us 
advertising 
classifieds 
submissions 
jobs at CER 
internships 
CER Direct 
e-mail us 
 ARCHIVES 
year 2000 
year 1999 
by subject 
by author 
kinoeye 
books 
news 
search 
 MORE 
bookshop 
music shop 
video store 
conferences 
diacritics 
FreeMail 
papers 
links 

 

Letters Page Debate:
On PR and Extremism

Reacting to last week's letters on extremism and proportional representation in Europe, Mel Huang responds.

Proportional representation (PR) is a two-way street, as well as a double-edged sword. In some systems, it creates more stability; in others, it would cause massive chaos. However, I feel switching systems in any shape or form must be thought of with utmost prudence and consideration, since tinkering with the most basic philosophy of parliamentary democracy is a tough thing if done improperly or rashly.

Let's use two examples: Germany and Lithuania. While Germany is a more established democratic system, Lithuania is a young democracy from Central and Eastern Europe.

Clearly, if PR is done away with in Germany, the rise of extremist elements would be expected. Right now, due to the size of Germany and the five per cent rule, the extremist groups - usually established in a localised area - have not managed to get into the lower house of the Bundestag. However, if PR is eliminated in Germany and instead constituencies are established in a first-past-the-post system, some areas - especially the East - will indeed elect parties with neo-Nazi followings.

Germany's PR system has proven to be very stable. In the years of the Federal Republic of Germany (BRD), there has rarely been one-party rule. The Free Democrats (FDP) has played the role of kingmaker over the years, until recently, as die Grünen managed to become the coalition partner of the German Social Democratic Party (SPD). Though instead of seats being divided among the old Christian Democratic Union (CDU)/Christian Social Union (CSU), SPD and FDP set, the current breakdown is still remarkably stable.

Looking at Lithuania, it currently has a mixed system. Of the 141 seats in the Seimas, 70 are by PR and 71 in individual constituencies. The PR set, in effect, has been a way to give the biggest parties the ability to hold the most seats. In the two electoral cycles since the restoration of the Seimas, there has been overwhelming success by one polar side or the other - taking full advantage of the 70 PR seats.

However, among the 71 constituencies, there are also elected representatives of parties that are either radical, localised or non-influential. There is little doubt that people leaning towards radicalism - those I mentioned in my column several weeks ago - would find that prospect most appealing. In Lithuania, if PR is abandoned, it would create more instability.

Looking at much of Central and Eastern Europe, a total PR system or mixed PR system has been more of an advantage than a disadvantage. Party politics are still developing, and the parties do not have the long term stability and tradition of their counterparts in the West. Again, using Lithuania as an example, the five parties that got PR seats in the last general election have seen splits and spin-off parties formed. Abandoning PR in these countries could also give rise to more regionally based parties and movements basically created as a political vehicle for one individual. Political culture, like stability, has to be built up. Constant changing of electoral systems and amending of constitutions only erodes a state's sense of permanence - the bedrock of stability. Doing away with PR is not a panacea for newly re-established democracies nor functional PR countries.

Mel Huang

Read Ian Hall and Magali Perrault's article, "The Re-Austrianiastion of Central Europe"

Read Frank Glodek's letter, "Extremism and Proportional Reprensentation"


Tell us what you think

Post your response here.

Moving on:

THIS WEEK:
EU Focus:
Mel Huang
Between Helsinki and a Hard Place

Gusztáv Kosztolányi
Hungary Playing Hard to Get

Brian J Požun
Slovenia's Cities

Jens Boysen
German Hegemony

Rafał Riedel
Poland on Course

Robin Sheeran
Slovak Catch-up

Catherine Lovatt
Romanian Road to Reform

Comment:
Jan Čulík
Anarchists on Parade

Gusztáv Kosztolányi
Hungarian Censorship

Oliver Craske
Britain Looks East

Kinoeye:
Andrew James Horton
Director Aleksei Balabanov

Elke de Wit
Football Flick

Arts:
Wojtek Kość
Polish Sensation

Culture Calendar:
UK | USA

Debate:
Sam Vaknin
Balkan Terrorists

Mel Huang
PR and Extremism

News:
Albania
Austria
Belarus
Bulgaria
Czech Republic
Estonia
Germany
Hungary
Latvia
Lithuania
Poland
Romania
Serbia
Slovakia
Slovenia